Authors, Writers, Publishers, and Book Readers

Okay, so let me start with an example: A Christmas Carol. Does that book capture the setting and lifestyle simply because it was based in the time it was written? If Charles Dickens had lived in the twenty-first century, and had written the famous book, would it have been as successful? I mean, if you think about it, some of the best books based in the Victorian era were written during that time. The same goes for other famous literary works. But if you notice, there aren't very many successful books that are based in one era and written during another. At least, none that I can think of off hand though I'm sure there are some out there. So does that mean it would basically be a waste to write a book set in the past?
I can understand why people like Charles Dickens were so successful in creating a mental image of the world their characters lived in, because they lived during that time as well (or at least very close to that time). But people nowadays have only research to guide them. They never had that experience of living during the age of beggars and revolutions. And, as I'm sure most of you know this, the things we read online and in books is never 100% accurate. The world can often exaggerate a little, or hide the facts to protect us. So does that make it a good reason to stick to your own era and leave the past alone?

Views: 11

Comment by scribbler on June 5, 2010 at 4:57am
Hmmm, good question. If we can't be 100% accurate, should that prevent us from writing anything that's research based? I don't think so. Because what the Victorian writers of their day considered interesting enough to write about may be completely different from what a modern day writer would want to write about. We're lucky to live in the digital age where so much is readily accessible so easily.
Comment by Kay Elizabeth on June 7, 2010 at 5:29am
No way! We should explore all the options. Why restrict yourself to the world you're living in? If we did that, the fantasy and sci-fi genres bite the dust too. Imagination knows no bounds.


You need to be a member of to add comments!


Sponsored Links

Most Active Members

1. Edward F. T. Charfauros

San Diego, CA, United States

2. RF Husnik

Green Bay, WI, United States

3. Rosemary Morris

Watford, United Kingdom

© 2018   Created by   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service